Don’t want to read the whole review? Click to jump to the Skinny Review.
Well, it took me a number of months to get into this book. To say that I was disappointed is such an understatement – this book was MEDIOCRE, to say the least!
I was looking forward to this book since I read Lady Bridget’s Diary last year because I liked James. He was written as such a cool and caring brother and the romance hinted at between him and Meredith was a tease that I WANTED to read. Unfortunately, this book failed in both.
Reasons Why It’s Hard Out Here for a Duke Failed
It was disjointed
This book is set concurrently with the other three books in the series and because of this, I felt like the story was very fragmented. Fragmented to the point where if you haven’t read the other books in series, you would feel lost (and I have read the other books in the series and I FELT soooo lost!). Because of this, I was skimming some of the parts.
What happened to the chemistry that was hinted at in the previous books? I felt like part of James and Meredith’s romantic interludes happened in the other books that it was MISSING in their own book!
Sure, I liked how they met and I liked the issues surrounding their relationship AND this trope is one of my favorites, too! But I wanted MORE! I wanted more interactions and more moments showing how James and Meredith fell in love.
I’m not sure what went wrong! Maya Rodale is one of my favorite romance authors but I feel like this series missed the mark, for me at least. Her Bad Boys & Wallflowers series was AWESOME, actually.
This book was also inspired by The Princess Diaries and Grey’s Anatomy and I’m not getting the mash-up at all.
I’m not sure I can recommend this book at all. As much as I LOVED Lady Bridget’s Diary, books 2 and 3 were not my favorites.
This was a HOT MESS, in my opinion, and as much as I love Maya Rodale, she really missed the mark on this one.
What do you think about series that are set concurrently with the other books?